EXCEEDING THE LIMITS OF THE NECESSARY MEASURES TO DETAIN A PERSON WHO HAS COMMITTED A SOCIALLY DANGEROUS ACT
Keywords:
socially dangerous act, person, detention, necessary measures, if exceeded, premeditated murder, causing harm, crimeAbstract
In this article opinions on the issue of exceeding the limits of the necessary measures to detain a person who has committed a socially dangerous act were analyzed. It is also substantiated that premeditated murder, in excess of the necessary measures of detention of a person who has committed a socially dangerous act, is considered a murder clearly disproportionate to the degree of public danger of the crime committed or the circumstances of his detention and the establishment of harm caused to the person is of great importance. In addition, the author analyzes that in the theory of criminal law, the opinions of the authors are different on the grounds for causing harm in order to prevent a socially dangerous act, that is, scientists believe that the commission of a socially dangerous act or crime by a person may serve as a basis for causing criminal-legal harm. Also, this article reflects that the question of what socially dangerous act was committed by the relevant employee (a person hired by the special service), to what extent the harm can be caused by this person while performing an operational task remains a problem, and this, in turn , requires clarification in the law of the grounds and conditions for the commission of a socially dangerous act or other measure of causing harm in the performance of an operational task.
References
Sluskiy I.I. Obstoyatelstva, isklyuchayushiye ugolovnuyu otvetsvennost. – M., 1956. – B. 60. (Slusky I.I. Circumstances precluding criminal liability. - M., 1956. - p. 60);
Sluskiy I.I. Obstoyatelstva, isklyuchayushiye ugolovnuyu otvetsvennost. – M., 1956. – B. 60 (Slusky I.I. Circumstances precluding criminal liability. - M., 1956. - p. 60);
Ugolovniy zakon. Opit teoreticheskogo modelirovaniya / Otv. red. V.N.Kudryavsev, S.G.Kelina. – M., 1987. – B.128-129 (Criminal law. Experience in theoretical modeling / Ed. ed. V.N.Kudryavsev, S.G.Kelina. - M., 1987. - p.128-129);
O‘zbekiston Respublikasining Jinoyat kodeksi (2019 yil 1oktabrgacha bo‘lgan o‘zgartish va qo‘shimchalar bilan). Rasmiy nashr. – T., 2019. – 39-modda (Criminal Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan (as amended and supplemented until October 1, 2019). Official publication. - T., 2019. - Article 39);
Kurs ugolovnogo prava. Obshaya chast. Tom 1. Uchebnik dlya VUZov. /Pod red. V.S. Komissarov. − M. 2002. – S. 291 (Criminal Law course. General Part. Issue 1. Textbook fot High Schools / Under edition of V.S. Komissarov. − M. 2002. – p. 291);
Popov A. N. Obstoyatelstva, isklyuchayushiye prestupnost deyaniya. − SPb., 1998.− S. 28 (Popov A. N. Circumstances precluding criminal liability. – Saint-Petersburg., 1998. - p. 28);
O‘zbekiston Respublikasi Oliy sudi Plenumining “Ruhiy kasallikka chalingan shaxslarga nisbatan tibbiy yo‘sindagi choralarni qo‘llash bo‘yicha sud amaliyoti to‘g‘risida”gi 2008 yil 12 noyabr 23-sonli qarori. (Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Uzbekistan No. 23 of November 12, 2008 “On Judicial Practice in the Application of Medical Measures to Persons with Mental Illness”) https://lex.uz/docs/1601125
Fayzullayeva T.X. Tibbiy yo‘sindagi majburlov choralarini ta’minlash muammolari. Yurid. fan. nomz… dis. avtoref. – T., 2009. – B. 25 (Fayzullayeva T.X. Problems of Enforcement of Medical Coercion. Resume of thesis for PhD degree. T., 2009. - P. 25.);
Sidorov B V. Prichinenie vreda pri zaderjanii prestupnika // Sovetskaya yustitsiya, 1990. – № 3. –P. 10–13 (causing damage to criminal in prevent to crime. Sovetskaya yustitsiya, 1990. – № 3. – p. 10–13);
Kurs ugolovnogo prava. Obshaya chast. Uchebnik dlya VUZov. Tom 1. /Pod red. V.S. Komissarov. − M. 2002. − S. 289 Kurs ugolovnogo prava. Obshaya chast. Tom 1. Uchebnik dlya VUZov. /Pod red. V.S. Komissarov. − M. 2002. – S. 291 (Criminal Law course. General Part. Issue 1. Textbook fot High Schools / Under edition of V.S. Komissarov. − M. 2002. – p. 289);
Kadnikov N. G. Obstoyatelstva, isklyuchayushiye prestupnost deyaniya: Uchebnoe posobie. – M., 1998. – S. 24 (Kadnikov N. G. Circumstances excluding the criminality of the act: Textbook. - M., 1998. - p. 24.);
Tishkevich I.S. Oborona i neobxodimost // Zakonnost. 1992, – № 4. – S. 28–31. (Tishkevich I.S. Defense and necessity // Zakonnost. 1992, – № 4. – p. 28–31.)
O‘zbekiston Respublikasi Oliy sudi Plenumining 2004 yil 24 sentabrdagi “Qasddan odam o‘ldirishga oid ishlar bo‘yicha sud amaliyoti i to‘g‘risida”gi 13-sonli qarori (Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Uzbekistan No. 13 on September 24, 2004 “On Judicial Practice in Cases of Intentional Murder”) https://lex.uz/docs/2892369
Mirzayev A.A. Prestupleniya protiv Respubliki Uzbekistan. Ugolovno-pravovie i kriminologicheskie aspekti: Monografiya. –T., 2007. – S. 82 (Mirzaev A.A. Crimes against the Republic of Uzbekistan. Criminal Law and Criminological Aspects: Monograph. -T., 2007. - p. 82.);
Rajabova M.A. Diniy ekstremizm va terrorchilik: uning ildizi qaerda? Maqsadi nima? Unga qarshi qanday kurashish kerak? – T., 2000. – B. 143 (Rajabova M.A. Religious extremism and terrorism: where are its roots? What is the purpose? How to fight it? - T., 2000. - P. 143);
Tadjixanov B.U. Terrorizmning huquqiy tavsifi: O‘quv qo‘llanma. – T., 2006. – B.61 (Tadjixanov B.U. Legal Description of Terrorism: Textbook. - T., 2006. - p.61.);
Toxirov F. Jinsiy jinoyatlarni kvalifikatsiya qilish asoslari. – T., 2006. – B. 134 (Tokhirov F. Bases of qualification of sexual crimes. - T., 2006. - P. 134);
S.S.Niyozova. Prevention of Crime in the Family and the Role of Victimology in the Republic of Uzbekistan. International Journal of Advanced Science and Technology Vol. 29, No. 3, (2020), pp. 3962.
Bakunov P. Bosqinchilik uchun javobgarlik: O‘quv qo‘llanma / Mas’ul muharrir dos. M. Usmonaliyev. – T., 2008. – B. 49 (Bakunov P. Responsibility for aggression: Textbook / Editor-in-Chief Assoc. M. Usmonaliyev. - T., 2008. - P. 49);
O‘zbekiston Respublikasi Oliy sudining “Respublika sudlari tomonidan ommoviy tartibsizliklar uchun javobgarlik to‘g‘risidagi qonunlarni qo‘llash amaliyoti bilan bog‘liq ayrim masalalar haqida”gi 1996 yil 20 dekabr 38-sonli qarori (Resolution of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Uzbekistan No. 38 of December 20, 1996 “On some issues related to the practice of application of the law on liability for mass riots by the courts of the Republic”) https://sud.uz/
Tureskiy N.N. Teoreticheskie problemi obstoyatelstv, isklyuchayushix prestupnost deyaniya, po ugolovnomu zakonodatelstvu respubliki Kazaxstan. Avtoreferat.dok.yur.navuk. – Sankt-Peterburg, 2005. – S. 37. (Turensky N.N. Theoretical problems of circumstances excluding the criminality of the act according to criminal legistlation of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Resume of thesis for DSc. – Saint Petersburg, 2005. – p.37)
Ivanov A.B. Institut prichineniya vreda pri zaderjanii litsa, sovershiv-shego prestuplenie. Avtoref. dis…. kand. yurid. nauk. – M., 1999. – S.13 (Ivanov A.V. The institution of causing harm during the arrest of a person who has committed a crime. Resume of thesis for PhD - M., 1999. - P.13);
Rustamboyev. M.X. O‘zbekiston Respublikasi Jinoyat kodeksiga sharhlar. Umumiy qism. −T., 2006. – B. 36–37 (Rustamboyev. M.X. Comments on the Criminal Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan. General section. −T., 2006. - P. 36–37);
Rustamboyev M.X. O‘zbekiston Respublikasi jinoyat huquqi kursi. Umumiy qism. T.1. –T., 2010. – B. 366 (Rustamboyev M.X. Course of Criminal Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan. General section. T.1. –T., 2010. - P. 366)
Khakimov Komil. (2021). Сriminological Characteristic of the Crimecommitted in the Case of Affect and the Identity of the Perpetrator. Annals of the Romanian Society for Cell Biology, 6980–6994. Retrieved from https://www.annalsofrscb.ro/index.php/journal/article/view/866
Khakimov K. Affect (Strong Mental Excitement) as means of legal structure in a condition of relief and penalty //Review of law sciences. – 2018. – Т. 2. – №. 4. – С. 21
